Is eating Maggi instant noodles really bad for health?
Wire baskets of noodles being readied for flash frying:
Last time I wrote an answer to this question, I was doing it from my cell phone. Due to repeated inquiries and questions from fellow members of Quora I have decided to edit my answer, provide a bit of background and sources.
I will not be talking about Lead content/MSG controversy. That is all over the news/internet/social networks anyways. I will be talking only about what was known since the past 15 years or so.
Partly because our uncle had a Farsaan factory (an Indian deep fried snack item) and was once upon a time interested in setting up a “Maggi” (instant noodles) plant.
And when I say Maggi here, It applies to almost all Instant noodles in the market. That includes Ramen (Nissin), Yippie (ITC), Knorr, etc.
That also includes Atta noodles, oat noodles, curry etc.
It does not, I repeat , does not include conventional pasta, conventional noodles, sewaiyan, or anything that is not labelled “Instant” or “2 minutes”
Now I will try to make it simple and break it down so that everyone can understand.
1. Ever wonder why Maggi gets cooked in just 2 minutes ?
2. Have you noticed why the packaging of Maggi is so thin ?
3. Wonder why it has a longer shelf life then most other products ?
4. Why do people think that something like “bikaneri bhujia sev ” is un healthy while Maggi is supposedly healthy because it is “boiled” ?
5. Ever wonder why Maggi (basically noodles in hot soup) which is tasty, filling, with a big marketing budget and sold by MNC’s like Nestle so cheap?
I mean it is cheaper then a sada dosa at a darshini and yet so tasty and filling.
Maggi is made of maida. Even your atta maggi is mainly made of maida. Then it is deep fried in Vanaspati (Dalda). Dalda is mainly Trans fat.
Why Dalda? Because it has 3 times the longer shelf life compared to vegetable oil plus it’s tastier.
Why is it deep fried. ? So that it’s easier to cook, faster to cook,
remember, 2 minute ruk sakte hain. More of a death tune.
Dalda or Trans fat is perhaps the worst thing in the world we are still stuffing ourselves with.
Always remember vegetable oil > saturated fats > Trans fat.
Even ghee or butter are better alternatives then Trans fat.
And I have not even mentioned the Sodium (Salt) part till now.
It is poison, my dear fellow members. Even if it is lead free. Especially for the young ones.
Are you so busy that you cannot spare extra ten minutes to make noodles properly? Or cook yourself some pasta?
Is it so addictive, the savory taste of MSG?
Most importantly I want this to be a message to all the young parents, who think Maggi is healthy because it is boiled while samosa/kachori/pakora/dosa are unhealthy.
Making of Instant noodles:
Wikipedia article on Instant Noodles: Instant noodle
Another opinion article on Ramen (Instant noodles), such articles abound in the net, but it is difficult to confirm their sources:
2 minute kya , 2 century bhi ruk sakte hain is Maggi ke liye.
MY ANSWER IS MAINLY FOCUSED ON MSG – Since Maggi isn’t the only food item that contains it.
Monosodium Glutamate – MSG (commonly known as Ajinomoto) enhances the taste of the food.
It is not only present in Maggi but in mostly all packaged food items.
It’s just that presently Maggi is in the limelight.
There is always a permitted quantity which is not allowed to be exceeded by the did companies (but they are always.. Maggi contains 6 times the lead it’s permitted to )
It’s present everywhere around.. Now it depends whether this topic will stretch or will Nestle be able to suppress this issue like Coca Cola did when tests prove it harmful.
If it stretches further.. Through media and public.. Fingers will be pointed at other food items too and a mass check might be done.
But you can’t completely eliminate MSG from the market.. As, if not in packaged foods it is used in high quantity in Chinese food and other street food items too.
One should themselves keep a check and reduce the packaged food items consumption.
If it’s so harmful, why is it put ?
It is increasingly found in many packaged food items as it is a taste enhancer.
Ajinomoto is nothing but a Japanese firm named Ajinomoto Corp.
It produces this Ajinomoto food enhancer, in which the main ingredient is this monosodium glutamate commonly known as MSG.
You won’t find or notice any side effects of MSG..But believe me EVERYTHING IN ACCESS IS BAD! And since it is used in so many packaged things and Street/Food at restaurants..MSG can be a slow killer.
The health effect that it has at first are quite mild. But with expense of time they become severe.
Here below is the list of some Side effects caused by this dangerous ingredient.
- Headache: This is a very common side effect of MSG. You normally get it. But due to continue intake of MSG this mild headache can take form of migraine. This migraine can be very severe.
- Overstimulates the nerves: As already discussed MSG is a neurotransmitter. It stimulates the nerves and misbalances the neurotransmitters. This leads to an unhealthy body.
- Heart effects: Excess intake doesn’t even leave heart unaffected. It leads to irregular heartbeats, cardiac muscles arrest and Chest pains.
- Burning sensation in the facial region is quite common due to regular intake of MSG.
- Pregnant women have to be very cautious regarding this ingredient as the breakdown of the barrier which would mean your baby is exposed to every substance in your blood, good or bad, in equal proportion as you.
- Even small kids should completely avoid consumption of MSG.
- MSG can be a reason for problems like blood pressure, thyroid issues, diabetes, asthma, food allergies and also obesity.
- Excess sweating is also a very common side effects of MSG.
- Nausea and weakness can also be felt after consumption of MSG
- It can also damage the retina of the eyes
- This ingredient can also be a reason forcausing cancer.
Items That Contain MSG
- Ready to eat food packets
- Dehydrated soup packets
- Dehydrated gravy packets
- Instant noodles and cup noodles.
- Preserved fish
- All kinds of sausages
- Tomato ketchup
- Potato wafers
- Soya sauce
- All canned and preserved foods
- All fast food items, especially Chinese
These food items should be completely avoided. If you don’t, you are risking your life to an ingredient that will kill you slowly.
Prefer food items made at home, basically organic and unprocessed food. I’m not saying that you should never eat these items.You can make all these items at home without the use of this dangerous MSG.
After knowing all this, I’m pretty sure that you will avoid all kinds of ready-made food items. Not completely, but still you will try.
See, life is very precious. Don’t pay high prices just for satisfying your taste buds. I will just say maintain one thing ‘say no to Ajinomoto or this ingredient MSG’
- Ensure that when you eat out there is no MSG added in the food item. When you buy products make sure that they are free of MSG.
Looking for an easy way to exceed customer expectations?
Unlock a health and wellness ecom experience that wows with a fast, flexible platform built for growth.
Of course it’s bad for health. Even keeping aside the current controversy about MSG or lead or whatever being over permissible limits, I’m surprised anyone thought Maggi was even remotely healthy. Not just Maggi, but also Top Ramen, Sunfeast Pasta, Knorr soups, and any instant foods.
It is processed food. It’s packaged, which means it has preservatives. It’s made of maida and has high amounts of refined carbs. It has high fructose corn syrup (which is staple of most processed foods). It has high amounts of sugar, salt, and fat — the three addictive ingredients foods that keep us wanting to eat more of it even if not hungry. The noodles especially contain trans fats. It contains a gazillion artificial chemicals like colorants and flavoring chemicals (in the masala) and texturants (in the noodles) because processed foods do not really retain their natural flavors. The foods have to be recreated to resemble natural food, and that’s done all artificially. To extend its shelf life, the components of Maggi are refined and isolated, and are stripped of essential nutrients and fibers. This not only extends the amount of time you can keep sealed Maggi at home, it also makes you less full after consumption and you end up eating more and more. Removing essential nutrients fills you with empty calories: you need less energy to chew and swallow it, and you burn less afterward during digestion because the foods are almost already broken down when they enter your system. If left aside after cooking, it coagulates into a lump. Maggi could actually be a leading factor in causing obesity.
Plus, like someone tweeted, it’s ridiculously inexpensive and can be made in four minutes. How could this possibly be healthy?
why only media target on maggi why not on this
media will never inform you??
Nestle company accepts that they add juice extracted from Beef in chocolate Kitkat.
media never informed you ???
That in a case in Chennai high court Fair & Lovely company accepted that the cream contains the oil from Pig fats !!
media never informed us that Vicks is banned in how many countries of Europe ! There it has been declared as slow poison ! But in our country we see it’s advertising on TV whole day !!
media never informed us that Life bouy is neither bath soap nor toilet soap ! But it’s
a Cabolic soap used for bathing animals !
Europe uses Life bouy for Dogs ! And in our country millions of humans use it !!
media never informed us ! ???????????
That Coke, Pepsi is in reality toilet cleaner ! it has been proved that it contains 21 types of different poisons ! And it’s sale is banned in the canteen of indian parliament ! But it is sold in whole country !!
media never informed us ????
That foreign companies selling health tonics like Boost
Protin-ex., were tested in Delhi at All India Institute (which houses biggest laboratory in india) and it was found that it is made from the waste left after oil is extracted from Groundnut ! Which is food for animals ! From this waste they make health tonic !!
media never informed us ??????
When Amitabh Bachhan was operated in hospital for 10 long hours !
Doctor had to cut and remove large intestine !! and doctor had told him that it has rotten due to drinking of soft drinks like Coke, Pepsi ! And then he stopped advertising coke
Media is faithful to the advertisers.
Lots of people enjoy Pizzas today.
Let’s have a look over pizza companies
Papa John’s Pizza
California Pizza Kitchen
These are all american companies,
Note:- to make Pizza tasty…
E-631 flavor Enhancer is added which is made from Pork or Pig meat.
● Attention friends if following codes are mentioned on food packs then you should know what you are unknowingly consuming.
E 322 – Beef
E 422 – Alcohol
E 442 – Alcohol & Chemical
E 471 – Beef & Alcohol
E 476 – Alcohol
E 481 – mixture of Beef and Pork
E 627 – Dangerous Chemical
E 472 – mixture of Beef, meat & Pork
E 631 – Oil extracted from Pig fats.
● Note – you will find these codes mostly in products of foreign companies like :- Chips , Biscuits , Chewing Gums, Toffees, Kurkure and Maggi !
● Don’t ignore pay your kind attention atleast for the well being of your kids, if in doubt then search by yourself through your sources if not internet. (Google)
● Look at ingredient on Maggi pack, you will find flavor (E-635 ).
● Also look for following codes on Google :-
E100, E110, E120, E140, E141, E153, E210, E213, E214, E216, E234, E252, E270, E280, E325, E326, E327, E334, E335, E336, E337, E422, E430, E431, E432, E433, E434, E435, E436, E440, E470, E471, E472, E473, E474, E475, E476, E477, E478, E481, E482, E483, E491, E492, E493, E494, E495, E542, E570, E572, E631, E635, E904.
Kindly forward it to your family and friends to spread awareness.👈👈👈👍👍
Apart from the facts that some other people have mentioned, it was just recently found that it contains MSG (no, not the Messenger of God, but Monosodium Glutamate) and Lead more than permissible limits.
Actually, Lead was 1700 frickin times more than the permissible limit!
On a separate note, as a matter of fact, I just only a few days back discovered that Nestle, as a company doesn’t give two shits about its consumers at an extreme level. No ethics. No moral values. Just profit.
I shit you not, I just found out that there’s been a call for a Nestle boycott since 1977.
So, I’m almost done with anything nestle.
Sorry if I sound like an activist. I’m not. I just told you what I’ve read and concluded in the last one week. You can google 🙂
Have COVID vaccine questions? Get expert answers.
It’s normal to have questions about the COVID vaccines. We have answers. Learn more today.
Oh just stop this madness!!!!!!!!!!!! Seriously!!!! such sanctimoniousness is so uncalled for. This is nothing but the Indian Government’s illustrious show of being pro-active about food safety…….which is total BULL-CRAP.
Maggi is SAFE! At least safer than the vegetables we buy at the market-place.
Do you have any idea what you eat??? Lead within ‘permissible limits’ is a JOKE if you consider the items we buy at the market every week. Just recently a batch of Alphonso mangoes were sent back from a country for high pesticide content. A crop consignment in UP was done away with because the irrigation waters were derived from a nearby waste-canal. These are cases that luckily saw the light of exposure. The tomatoes that you eat, the green veggies that you think are healthy, pomegranate, watermelon, even the fish that you buy are full of dangerous colours and here we are, acting all ‘holier than thou’, taking pride in bashing up an MNC that maintains international food standards across the globe.
I have never seen such a singular example of a rampaging media destroying a brand that is responsible for having created a veritable food culture in the country. Who in all honesty can say that s/he doesn’t owe moments of pure pleasure to a hot bowl of maggi noodles? Can you imagine your childhood without Maggi? What do you do when you haven’t had time to cook all day and need to eat. You EAT MAGGI! That product has sustained generations after generations. Nestle made a conscious decision to exclude external addition of MSG -which is nothing but ‘ajinomoto’- years back. You have tonnes and tonnes of ajinomoto when you savour eating Chinese food in restaurants. ‘Thin packet’, ‘fried’……..oooooooooooo, that is so bad!!! ‘OMG, you meanie, you are feeding me poison!!!!’ Oh please! Maggi is what you call yourself an amateur cook for!!
Maggi samples were sent for tests to labs abroad by Nestle itself. It was clearly proved to be safe. Yes, the taste-maker turned out to have extra lead levels in Delhi but the company clearly said that when you mix it with the cake and cook it, lead levels are perfectly within limits. There is more lead in the air you breathe than in a packet of Maggi . So many states banned it even without testing it. Maharashtra and Goa gave it a clean chit but clearly recanted under media pressure. The media created such a hullabaloo about Kerela’s ban. It was A LIE! A certain co-operative society decided not to sell it. This was publicized as a state ban by journalists hungry to bash whoever they can get their hands on. Kerela had given Maggi a clean chit too. This, I read in a tiny headline at the corner of the ET website. WOW!
It all started in UP right. That guy, The ‘so-called’ hero…..O, there’s a dispute about that. They are having a fight over who gets to be called the hero. Did you know that? The samples tested were EXPIRED for God’s sake!!!!! Even Nestle does not advocate consumption of its expired items. The very same UP is reluctant to ban Maggi even today!!! Karnataka hasn’t banned it and West Bengal has been facing real problems for refusing to ban it. The mayor was harangued until the CM had to step in and say that the samples were tested safe, what to do??!!!!! Now, isn’t it sad that it turned out to be safe!!! Lead content lead content……please!!!! FSSAI…PEOPLE IN GLASS HOUSES SHOULDN’T THROW STONES AT OTHERS!!!!!
I am desperately trying to stock up on Maggi. Do it friends while you still can….or don’t….if you think it is poison……I pity you all for living in such a fools’s paradise. Maggi is probably safer than whatever you plan to substitute it with. It pains me to see such a popular and dear brand being fed to the dogs because the food authority sees an opportunity to earn ‘compensation’ (check today’s papers), an attention seeking lawyer gets a bit of cheap publicity for suing filmstars, newspapers get to bash somebody just like Arnab Goswami gets to scream his lungs out at someone and he loves it.
I pray that the brand is back as soon as possible and Nestle India, please get your stuff tested at least to stop the screaming media if for nothing else. Hostels boys in Bihar and Jharkhand are already stocking up and so are others. Please return because our stocks aren’t gong to last forever!!!!!!!!!
Yes. Due to these reasons-
- It is made from Maida.
- It is double deep fried in oil to give it a non-sticky and waxy appearance.
- It has high sodium content.
See Ketan Bhatia ‘s answer for full explanation : Ketan Bhatia’s answer to Is there any harm in having Maggi everyday?
If you have the time and would like to know about all the harmful ingredients that we consume in food products, here you go.
- Hydrogenated oil
They are the primary source of trans fat. Trans fats are twice as difficult for the body to dissolve as saturated fats. They boost bad cholesterol (LDL) and reduce good cholesterol (HDL). Manufacturers love it because it reduces cost. They’re active agents of heart disease, diabetes, nutritional deficiencies and cellular deterioration.
Found in : crackers, cookies, baked goods, salad dressings, breads and chips.
Monosodium glutamate. MSG in all of its forms is considered a neurotoxin because it has been shown to damage nerve cells by overexciting them to the point of cell death. MSG is also a chemoinducer of obesity, type II diabetes and metabolic syndrome.
Found in canned soup, diet beverages, an array of popular fast food, packaged sausages and frankfurters, beef stew, instant soups, salad dressing and some packaged vegetarian foods.
- Artificial sweeteners
Sucralose (Splenda) Advertised as “natural” because it’s made from sugar, but scientists replace three hydrogen-oxygen molecules with chlorine atoms and change its chemical composition. They result in diabetes and obesity.
- HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP
They are being advertised as being similar to cane sugar, which they are not. It inhibits leptin and damages tissue and can contain toxic levels of mercury.
So what? Stop eating packaged foods and eat only fruits and vegetables? Not so easy, that’s where corporations like Monsanto come in. But that’s a different story altogether!
As a rule of thumb, anything that’s packaged and can be preserved for long is unhealthy. There are very rare food items on this earth that remain healthy after they are preserved.
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF REASONS WHY INSTANT NOODLES LIKE MAGGI MIGHT BE BAD FOR YOU. IN THIS ARTICLE, WE EXPLORE THE VARIOUS INGREDIENTS IN INSTANT NOODLES THAT MAKE YOU WONDER WHY IS MAGGI BAD FOR YOU .
1. IT CONTAINS REFINED FLOUR OR MAIDA
Thе tеrmѕ “Wheat flоur” оr “rеfіnеd whеаt flour” оr “all-purpose flоur” refer tо Maida. Atta іѕ rеfеrrеd tо еіthеr аѕ “Attа” or “Whоlе wheat flour”.
2. IT IS DEEP FRIED
Aѕ per fооd lаw, іt іѕ a mаndаtоrу requirement that іngrеdіеntѕ bе mеntіоnеd in order оf рrороrtіоn, і.е. thе іngrеdіеnt whісh forms thе lаrgеѕt реrсеntаgе оf the рrоduсt muѕt соmе fіrѕt аnd so оn.
Thіѕ means that the 2nd lаrgеѕt соnѕtіtuеnt оf Maggi Noodles іѕ Edible Vеgеtаblе oil! So where is it?The оіl is асtuаllу used in flаѕh-frуіng thе рrоduсt.
3. DANGEROUS LEVELS OF SODIUM
Thе amount of Sodium іn the расk іѕ сlоѕе to 46 % of the dаіlу rеԛuіrеmеnt. Whісh is a Lоt !
4. IT MIGHT CONTAIN LEAD
A few ѕаmрlеѕ оf Maggi were соllесtеd іn Uttаr Prаdеѕh аnd tested for реrmіѕѕіblе ingredients at Kolkata’s referral lаbоrаtоrу. Maggi was fоund to соntаіn 17 parts реr mіllіоn оf lead, еnоrmоuѕlу сrоѕѕіng thе permissible limit of mеrе 0.01 раrtѕ per million оf lead.
5. IT IS NOTHING BUT EMPTY CALORIES
Mаggі’ѕ nutrіtіоnаl summary:
Thеrе аrе 360 саlоrіеѕ in a 1 block ѕеrvіng of Mаggі Mаѕаlа Nооdlеѕ.Cаlоrіе breakdown: 37% fаt, 55% саrbѕ, 8% protein.
Nоw , gо do thе math yourself !
6. PRESENCE OF TRANS-FATS
Trans fаtѕ аrе twісе аѕ dіffісult fоr thе bоdу tо dіѕѕоlvе as ѕаturаtеd fats. Thеу bооѕt bаd сhоlеѕtеrоl (LDL) and reduce gооd сhоlеѕtеrоl (HDL). Mаnufасturеrѕ love іt bесаuѕе it rеduсеѕ соѕt. Thеу’rе асtіvе аgеntѕ of hеаrt dіѕеаѕе, dіаbеtеѕ, nutritional deficiencies аnd cellular dеtеrіоrаtіоn.
7. CAUSES ACIDITY
Cіtrіс acid (E 330), аn асtіvе іngrеdіеnt іn instant nооdlеѕ, еnhаnсеѕ thе асtіvіtу оf many antioxidants, but іѕ nо antioxidant bу itself. It іѕ mаіnlу used аѕ аn acidity regulator as wеll аѕ aroma соmроund. In addition іt іnсrеаѕеѕ gеl соnѕіѕtеnсу іn mаrmаlаdеѕ аnd dесrеаѕеѕ еnzуmаtіс brоwnіng in fruits аnd fruіt рrоduсtѕ.
8. MIGHT CONTAIN MONO SODIUM GLUTAMATE (MSG)
Monosodium glutаmаtе (MSG, аlѕо knоwn аѕ sodium glutаmаtе) іѕ thе ѕоdіum ѕаlt оf glutаmіс асіd, one of the most аbundаnt naturally оссurrіng nоn-еѕѕеntіаl amino асіdѕ. You mіght be knоwіng іt bу thе mоrе commonly knоwn “Ajino-Moto” brаnd.
MSG is used in the fооd іnduѕtrу аnd асtѕ аѕ a flаvоr enhancer.
Cоnѕumіng high аmоunt of MSG can lеаd tо the fоllоwіng ѕhоrt-tеrm рrоblеmѕ:
Weakness оf Armѕ & Lеgѕ.
Burning ѕеnѕаtіоn оf Mouth.
Hives оr Othеr Types of Allergic rеасtіоnѕ tо the skin.
9. HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP
HFCS and саnе ѕugаr are NOT bіосhеmісаllу іdеntісаl оr processed thе same wау bу thе bоdу. High fructose соrn syrup іѕ аn іnduѕtrіаl fооd product аnd fаr from “nаturаl” оr a nаturаllу occurring ѕubѕtаnсе.
10. DRIED VEGETABLES
Thеѕе vеgеtаblеѕ аrе dеvоіd оf аnу nutrition. These are unhealthy аѕ they are already dеhуdrаtеd, you are better оff not аddіng аnу оf thеѕе. Thе amount оf “vegetables” dеhуdrаtеd is lіtеrаllу nоt еvеn hаndful. Wе аrе nоt аwаrе of their еԛuірmеnt and thе рrосеѕѕ of hоw they аrе dеhуdrаtеd.
almost everybody should have his own version of recollections associated with Maggi, like preparation Maggi in this encampment with friends, having it once guests call in while not a warning, or enjoying it whereas having a late-night speak with a full cousin you met when an extended time. Maggi may be a life-saver for those that choose a camp or keep in an exceeding hostel while not oldsters. regardless of however choosey a toddler is, you’ll rarely realize a child World Health Organization doesn’t love Maggi. Here area unit the various ways that to cook Maggi Noodles. If you’re wanting food choices, Maggi is that the thanks to going.
Maggi contains MSG
MSG, metal salt or seasoning, is the metal salt of the glutamines acid, Associate in Nursing extravagantly occurring non-essential amino alkanoic acid MSG. it’s a form of focused salt that is added to a food to boost flavor. This version of glutaminic acid may be naturally made within the body, however, MSG is processed, and comes from sugar beets when fermentation. This processed seasoner will cause varied adverse effects, like hives, itching, skin rash, vomiting, nausea, heart irregularities, asthma, migraine, depression, and seizures.
Maggi is formed of maida
Maida is refined flour that we have a tendency to typically avoid in building bread and biscuits. Maggi is actually made up of maida, that is formed when processing whole grain flour. throughout this process, the bran, husk and germ area unit removed, that area unit may be the foremost nutritive elements of the seed. So, the Maggi that you simply eat is empty of any such nutrients. However, there area unit Atta and rice versions of Maggi obtainable out there, that area unit a minimum of somewhat healthier than its regular variant.
Maggi is therefore high in salt
Have you ever thought of what makes Maggi therefore yummy? it’s in all probability salt. One block, a hundred MSG or one serving of Maggi contains 1170mg of salt, that is nearly five hundredth of the utmost quantity counseled by Department of Agriculture. Most of the salt is contained in its seasoning pouch, however, the noodles themselves contain some salt too. Salt is Associate in the Nursing ingredient that ends up in several issues in your health, particularly if you’re a high-pressure level patient. High salt intake ends up in the variety of heart connected problems too. So, you ought to avoid feeding Maggi a minimum of for its high salt content.
Maggi has dangerous fats
Maggi may be a processed food, and it’s loaded with dangerous fats like trans fats and saturated fatty acids. after you investigate the label of Maggi, you’ll realize edible oil, syrup, sugar, flavor enhances, alternative|and several other} other agents that don’t seem to be sensible for health.
A lot of ‘pure ghee’ sweets sold all over india contain flavored beef bone oil.think about that lol.